Wednesday, September 09, 2009

Article of the Day

Obama and the Bureaucratization of Health Care, by Sarah Palin.

3 comments:

Trashcan said...

I don't see what the problem with death panels is. Obviosuly nobody should say that a person is no longer allowed to get health care, but there's nothing wrong with saying at some point the state will no longer pay for it. That is a relevant point whether we adopt some sort of health care reform, or just keep going with medicare. The problem is that there is crystal ball to look into that says this person will live for 1 year and it will cost 150,000 to keep them alive for that one year. at that point the state could say this is no longer cost effective, we are going to spend that 150,000 on improving school systems for children. In fact i very much believe that it would be better for society if the government drastically scaled down on money spend on seniors ( i don't remember, but i think it's around half the budget between social security and medicare) and increased spending on children.

Aras said...

that's the whole problem, you goof. if you have private insurance you can choose a more expensive policy that will guarantee you coverage no matter the cost--or not, it's up to you. if you are forced to pay for government insurance maybe you can't afford an additional policy anymore, so you're subject to a death squad.

Trashcan said...

My point was that medicare already exists for the elderly, and the federal government already spents huge amounts of money on the healthcare of the elderly, whether or not any healthcare bill goes through. I don't know how many elderly people have insurance through something other than medicare, but i would guess it's a low number.

Also nobody is going to be forced to choose a government option instead of a private option. The concern about the existence of a government option is that it would be subsidized, and possibly undercut private options forcing them out of business. Nobody suggested that somebody would be forced to pay for government insurance in addition to any private insurance you want. (except in the sense of taxes, but United states citizens aren't paying for nearly what they consume in government services already.)

This is my counter: